Resulting clips randomly out of sync

Dear Jiri,

Unfortunately it is a limitation in Logic, I am afraid there is not a lot we can do about it, without going back and removing the transitions, but we cannot do that as this was necessary to keep things compliant with ProTools. Its possible that Logic will improve what they import from the AAF, it might be worth asking them direct if you can ?

Yours sincerely
James

Yes, I'm checking it in Logic as that's the only app I have access to and I like to check before I send it off to the sound guy. Okay, I'll probably just send it the next time without checking and hope for the best :) Is that a Logic bug? Or intended behavior?

Dear Jiri,

To confirm are you using Logic ?

If we look at your xml and create an AAF in 4.5.4 and review this in ProTools all looks good.

Looking at the changes in code between 4.3.0 and 4.5.4 there is one change that could be upsetting Logic, this is where fades have been implemented as transitions rather than automation gain, and this would have changed the structure of the AAF we create.

Yours Sincerley

James

Hi Jira,

Apologies, as per my mail to you, we are looking into it now.

Yours sincerely

James

Version 4.5.4 from the App Store still exhibits the desyncing issue. The RLM version works correctly with the same XML (enclosed).

Please send me a license for this host ID: 04d9f5f3abaa

thanks,
Jiri

Thank you, I’ll try that ASAP.

Hi Stooovie,

This sounds like it might be an issue that has already been reported by another user. I will send you an email to download an older version of X2Pro whilst we look into this further.

Apologies for the inconvenience.

Daniel

This is a typical state of my X2Pro exports. There's even one subrole (Dialogue.port3) completely missing from the AAF.

https://imgur.com/yqKnUFq

FCPX 10.4.10, X2Pro 4.5.0. Clips are out of sync and on some clips, some channels are missing, even when they are NOT disabled or inactive in the FCPX sequence.

There are some compound clips and majority is multicams. I need to get this working for broadcast mixing. The XML is enclosed, image is here:



Resulting AAF is here: AAF

Please help. In the meantime, pls send me the 4.4.3 version. Thanks.